TurboTax vs H&R Block vs AlphaTax: Best Tax Software for Freelancers 2026

Introduction

Choosing the right tax software as a freelancer can mean the difference between maximizing your deductions and leaving thousands on the table. With variable income, business expenses, and quarterly tax obligations, you need more than basic tax filing software—you need a platform that works for your unique situation.

In this comprehensive comparison, we'll break down three popular options: TurboTax (the market leader), H&R Block (the traditional favorite), and AlphaTax (the AI-powered newcomer). We'll compare pricing, features, and real-world use cases to help you make the best decision for your freelance business in 2026.

Quick Comparison Table

TurboTax Self-Employed: The Market Leader

Overview

TurboTax Self-Employed is the most popular tax software in America, known for its user-friendly interface and comprehensive coverage of tax situations. Owned by Intuit (the makers of QuickBooks), TurboTax has been the go-to choice for freelancers and independent contractors for over 20 years. The software excels at guiding users through the filing process with a question-and-answer format that makes complex tax situations feel manageable.

Key Features

• Step-by-Step Tax Filing - Interview-style questions guide you through every deduction
• Schedule C Support - Full support for self-employment income (Form 1040 Schedule C)
• Quarterly Tax Reminders - Email reminders for estimated tax payment deadlines
• Max Refund Guarantee - Promises to find you the largest refund possible
• Live CPA/EA Support - On-demand help from tax professionals (additional cost)
• Import from QuickBooks - Seamless integration if you use QuickBooks for accounting
• Audit Support - Guidance if you're audited by the IRS (with TurboTax Premium)
• State Tax Returns - Includes one state return (additional states cost extra)
• Prior Year Returns - Can file up to 3 years of back taxes
• Mobile App - Snap photos of W-2s and 1099s for automatic import

Pricing

• Self-Employed Plan: $129 per federal return
• State Returns: $59 per state (if needed)
• Live CPA/EA Help: +$80-220 depending on service level
• Total Cost: $129-$408+ depending on needs

Best For

Individual freelancers with straightforward 1099 income who file taxes once per year and want a trusted, established brand with comprehensive audit support. Ideal for those who prioritize ease of use and are willing to pay premium pricing for a well-known name.

Pros

• Industry Standard - Most accountants and tax pros are familiar with TurboTax, making it easy to get help if needed
• Comprehensive Tax Coverage - Handles virtually every tax situation, from crypto to rental properties to stock options
• Excellent User Experience - Polished interface with clear explanations makes complex tax code understandable
• Guaranteed Accuracy - If TurboTax makes an error that results in penalties, they cover it (up to $100,000)
• Extensive Help Resources - Massive library of articles, videos, and community forums

Cons

• Expensive for Freelancers - At $129+ annually, it's 13x more expensive than some alternatives for similar features
• Annual Focus Only - Designed for year-end filing, not year-round tax planning or quarterly optimization
• Upsell Heavy - Constantly prompts upgrades to higher tiers or add-on services like live CPA help
• Limited Deduction Discovery - You need to know what to look for; software won't proactively suggest strategies

H&R Block Premium: The Hybrid Approach

Overview

H&R Block Premium (formerly called Premium & Business) combines online tax software with access to 10,000+ physical offices nationwide. Founded in 1955, H&R Block built its reputation on in-person tax preparation and has successfully transitioned to digital offerings. The Premium plan is designed for freelancers, contractors, and small business owners who want the flexibility of DIY software with the option to visit a local office if they get stuck.

Key Features

• Dual Filing Options - Start online, finish in-office, or vice versa
• Schedule C & Schedule E Support - Covers self-employment and rental property income
• Unlimited Expert Help - Ask questions to H&R Block tax professionals while preparing return
• Business Expense Categorization - Guides you through common freelance deductions
• Quarterly Tax Calculator - Helps estimate payments throughout the year
• Second Look Review - H&R Block reviews competitor-prepared returns for free
• Refund Advance Loans - Get your refund early (with fees)
• Small Business Tools - Mileage tracker, receipt organizer (basic features)
• State Returns Included - One state return included in Premium pricing
• Import Options - Import from major accounting software (QuickBooks, FreshBooks)

Pricing

• Premium Plan: $110 per federal return
• State Returns: $54 per state (first state often included with promotions)
• In-Office Consultation: $75-150 if you choose to finish with a tax pro
• Total Cost: $110-$314+ depending on needs

Best For

Freelancers who value the security of having in-person backup support available, or those in their first year of self-employment who might need extra guidance. Good for people who want a middle-ground between DIY software and full-service tax preparation.

Pros

• Hybrid Flexibility - Unique ability to switch between online and in-person help without starting over
• Competitive Pricing - Typically $10-20 cheaper than TurboTax Self-Employed for similar features
• Unlimited Expert Help - Unlike TurboTax which charges extra, Premium includes unlimited questions to tax pros
• Physical Locations - Peace of mind knowing you can walk into an office if things get complicated
• Second Look Promise - Will review your TurboTax return for free and find missed deductions

Cons

• Clunky User Experience - Interface feels dated compared to TurboTax; less intuitive navigation
• Still Expensive - At $110+, it's a significant annual cost for freelancers on tight budgets
• Year-End Focused - Like TurboTax, designed for annual filing rather than proactive year-round planning
• Limited Deduction Intelligence - Won't automatically discover missed deductions; you must know what to claim

AlphaTax: AI-Powered Tax Optimization for Freelancers

Overview

AlphaTax is positioned as "Tax Intelligence for the Modern Professional," offering a comprehensive, AI-powered tax optimization platform designed specifically for freelancers and small business owners. Unlike traditional competitors that charge per return or offer tiered pricing based on features, AlphaTax embraces an "everything included" approach—all features come with a single subscription price. The platform combines real-time income and expense tracking with intelligent tax strategy recommendations, making it ideal for freelancers who want proactive tax planning, not just annual filing preparation.

Key Features

• AI-Powered Tax Strategy Optimizer - Personalized, real-time optimization strategies with specific dollar savings displayed (e.g., SEP IRA contributions, QBI deductions, home office deductions)
• Receipt & Document AI Extraction - Automatically categorizes expenses from photos/PDFs; AI learns your business patterns
• Mileage Tracker with Method Comparison - Calculates both Standard Rate and Actual Expense methods, recommending the higher deduction
• Income & Expense Tracker - Multi-input system (bank sync coming soon, receipt uploads, statement PDFs, manual entry) with automatic AI categorization
• Quarterly Tax Estimator & Tracker - Monthly and quarterly tax estimation with breakdown by entity
• Retirement Optimizer - Tracks multiple retirement accounts, projects growth, compares contribution strategies (Traditional vs Roth, SEP IRA vs Solo 401k)
• Savings Growth Planner - Combines tax savings with retirement contributions showing projected growth across Conservative/Moderate/Growth/Aggressive scenarios
• Home Office Calculator - Compares Simplified Method vs Actual Expenses with detailed expense breakdown and strategic recommendations
• Home Affordability Analyzer - Evaluates home purchase feasibility using the 28% rule
• Budget Planner - Monthly and year-over-year income/expense projections by category
• Tax Reports - Monthly, quarterly, and annual reports with deduction summaries and optimization recommendations
• Professional CPA-Ready Export - PDF exports compatible with tax professionals
• Multiple Business Support - Manage multiple entities within one account

Pricing

• Monthly: $14/month (flat rate, all features included)
• Annual: $99/year (save $69)
• Free Trial: 7 days
• Note: 100% tax-deductible subscription cost

Best For

Freelancers and self-employed professionals who want active tax optimization throughout the year, not just tax preparation at filing time. Ideal for those with variable income, multiple income streams, vehicle/mileage deductions, home office setup, or who are serious about retirement planning. Perfect for users who value AI-driven recommendations and want to discover deductions they might otherwise miss.

Pros

• All-in-One Platform at Low Cost - $14/month includes tools that competitors charge extra for (TurboTax charges $120+ for self-employed, and H&R Block's freelancer packages are similarly priced). You get retirement planning, calculators, and optimization—no hidden upgrade costs.
• AI Finds Money You'd Miss - The Strategy Optimizer provides specific recommendations (identifying hundreds in potential tax savings proactively). Receipt categorization learns your patterns, reducing manual data entry. Most competitors require you to remember deductions; AlphaTax discovers them.
• Mileage Deduction Optimization - Unlike TurboTax (flat standard rate) and H&R Block, AlphaTax automatically calculates both methods and recommends which saves you more. This alone can be worth hundreds annually for service professionals.
• Quarterly Tax Planning - Real-time estimated quarterly tax calculations help you avoid underpayment penalties. Both TurboTax and H&R Block focus on year-end filing, not quarterly strategy.
• Financial Planning Beyond Taxes - Retirement projections, savings growth scenarios, and home affordability analysis go beyond what TurboTax and H&R Block offer, making it a lifestyle financial tool, not just tax software.

Cons

• Limited Bank Integration (Coming Soon) - While the Income & Expense Tracker supports receipt photos and PDF uploads today, bank account sync is still in development. TurboTax and H&R Block have fully automated bank connections now, reducing manual entry.
• No Tax Filing Integration Yet - AlphaTax doesn't file your taxes directly; you'll need to export and work with a CPA or use a filing service. TurboTax and H&R Block handle end-to-end filing (though AlphaTax's CPA-ready PDF export bridges some of this gap).
• Newer Platform with Smaller Feature Set - As a newer entrant, AlphaTax lacks some niche features established competitors offer (deduction guides, state tax-specific tools, etc.). The platform is actively developing but hasn't reached full feature parity with 20+ year-old competitors.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Pricing Breakdown (Annual Cost)

Scenario: Freelance graphic designer, single state filing

Key Insight: If you use a CPA for filing anyway, AlphaTax + CPA fees ($200-400) equals the total cost of TurboTax + CPA review ($188 + $200 = $388), but you get year-round optimization tools.

Feature Comparison: What You Actually Need as a Freelancer

1. Quarterly Tax Estimates

• TurboTax: Basic calculator, email reminders
• H&R Block: Calculator with breakdown
• AlphaTax: Real-time estimates with monthly tracking and entity breakdown ✅

2. Deduction Discovery

• TurboTax: Prompts common deductions, you must remember specifics
• H&R Block: Interview-style prompts
• AlphaTax: AI proactively suggests deductions based on your spending ✅

3. Mileage Tracking

• TurboTax: Standard rate only ($0.70/mile in 2025)
• H&R Block: Standard rate only
• AlphaTax: Compares standard vs. actual expenses, recommends higher ✅

4. Retirement Planning

• TurboTax: Not included
• H&R Block: Not included
• AlphaTax: Full optimizer comparing SEP IRA, Solo 401k, Traditional vs Roth ✅

5. Tax Filing

• TurboTax: Full e-file included ✅
• H&R Block: Full e-file included ✅
• AlphaTax: CPA-ready export only (must file separately)

6. Bank Sync

• TurboTax: Full integration ✅
• H&R Block: Full integration ✅
• AlphaTax: Coming soon (currently manual/receipt upload)

Which Should You Choose?

Choose TurboTax If:

• You need end-to-end filing in one place
• You value brand recognition and maximum audit support
• You're willing to pay premium pricing ($188+/year) for convenience
• You have a complex tax situation (crypto, rental income, stock options)
• You only think about taxes in March/April

Choose H&R Block If:

• You want the option of in-person support without committing upfront
• You need filing included but want to save $20-30 vs TurboTax
• You like the security of physical office locations near you
• You're comparing previous TurboTax returns (they'll review for free)
• You only think about taxes in March/April

Choose AlphaTax If:

• You want year-round tax optimization, not just filing
• You're looking for AI-powered deduction discovery to maximize savings
• You value retirement planning tools integrated with tax strategy
• You already work with a CPA (or plan to) and just need the data organized
• You want to pay 90% less than traditional software ($99/year vs $188/year)
• You make quarterly estimated payments and need ongoing tracking
• You have multiple income streams or run multiple businesses

Real-World Use Cases

Case Study 1: W-2 Employee with Side Gig

Profile: Full-time employee with W-2, occasional freelance work totaling $5K/year, no business expenses

Best Choice: TurboTax or H&R Block

Why: Minimal self-employment income with simple reporting; values one-and-done filing convenience; doesn't need year-round planning tools

Case Study 2: 1099 Marketing Consultant

Profile: Marketing consultant, $85K/year, multiple clients, home office, business expenses

Best Choice: AlphaTax

Why: Schedule C with numerous deductible expenses; AI deduction finder identifies missed write-offs (software, equipment, meals); quarterly tax estimates prevent underpayment penalties; home office calculator optimizes deduction method; saves $1,200+ annually in found deductions vs. $89 in software costs

Case Study 3: Uber/Lyft Driver

Profile: Rideshare driver, $45K/year, 15,000 miles driven, home office for admin work

Best Choice: AlphaTax

Why: Mileage method comparison (Standard vs. Actual) saves $400-600/year; tracks vehicle expenses automatically; quarterly estimates avoid penalties; $99/year vs. $188+ for competitors

Case Study 4: Freelance Developer with Retirement Goals

Profile: Software contractor, $120K/year, maxing SEP IRA, planning Solo 401k transition

Best Choice: AlphaTax

Why: Retirement optimizer compares SEP IRA vs. Solo 401k strategies (could save $5K+ annually in optimized contributions); quarterly tax planning with high variable income; AI finds business deductions (equipment, software, conferences); works seamlessly with CPA for filing; $99/year vs. $188+ for competitors

Case Study 5: First-Time Freelancer (Needs Hand-Holding)

Profile: Graphic designer, $35K/year, first year self-employed, overwhelmed by taxes

Best Choice: H&R Block Premium

Why: Wants in-person backup available at local office; willing to pay premium for peace of mind during first year; can transition to AlphaTax once comfortable with self-employment taxes

The Bottom Line

If you only do taxes once a year and want everything in one place: TurboTax or H&R Block are solid choices with decades of reliability.

If you want to think about taxes year-round and maximize every deduction: AlphaTax offers AI-powered optimization at a fraction of the cost, though you'll need to handle filing separately (via CPA or another service).

The best choice depends on whether you view taxes as an annual chore (TurboTax/H&R Block) or an ongoing financial strategy (AlphaTax).

Ready to Optimize Your Taxes?

If you're serious about maximizing your tax savings as a freelancer, try AlphaTax free for 7 days. See how much the AI Tax Strategy Optimizer can find in potential savings, track your quarterly estimates in real-time, and optimize your retirement contributions.

Last Updated: January 2026

Disclaimer: Tax laws change frequently. This comparison reflects 2026 pricing and features as of January 2026. Consult a licensed tax professional for specific advice about your situation.

Related Comparisons

• AlphaTax vs TurboTax - Detailed comparison
• AlphaTax vs H&R Block - Detailed comparison
• Compare All Tax Software - See all comparisons